Why martial arts do not work: 5 reasons
Self-defense: when the problem occurs, it is too late to understand
In most self-defense situations, 90% of martial arts (both traditional and modern), do not work as we expect.
Note – This article has been asked by one of our Core Course practitioners on Patreon (see how to attend our home study classes hereĀ Learn Kung Fu online: a beginner-to-expert course).
Unfortunately, when someone attacks / threatens us it is too late to understand that:
- The aggressionsĀ are always different – No one attacks as it happens in the classical collaborative gym simulations (read Self-defense: why 90% of martial arts does not work); no one will passively wait to be beaten by our preconfigured techniques; people react violently and their blows are not caresses (read How to use martial arts in a real fight)
- The street is not the gym – Fighting on the street we always risk our life and the adversaries are just 1 of the threats we inevitably face; even if we tap on our opponent’s shoulder he / she does not stop to strangle us (read The 6 types of martial clash) and there is no soft mattress on the ground to cushion our falls (read What are breakfalls and how to learn them)
- Titles, prizes, and participation in seminars have no value on the street – As Bruce Lee teaches (read The real Bruce Lee’s legacy), a belt, of whatever color it is, only serves to hold up the trousers (read When a belt becomes a blindfold); if the mind is not prepared to face the stress level of an unexpected clash and if the body is not conditioned by pain (read for example Conditioning check for the impact) and daily fatigue, our possibilities are near to zero (read Self-Defense: is it possible to always be ready to fight?)
- Real skills require real deep study – Spatial intelligence, timing and cunning are worth a hundred times speed, strength and technique (read also The most important skill in combat); a skill truly acquired is the one who comes at the right moment, spontaneously like breathing (read How to acquire special abilities)
- In a real scenario, to fight is the last option – If we attack first, we are the aggressors and not the victims (with all the legal consequences that it involves read Best martial arts for self-defense); in terms of personal safety, prevention, escaping and negotiation are 100 times more effective than any combat-related “solution” (read Personal defense: the S.A.F.E. method)
Martial preparation and the impact of the truth
It is at that exact moment, the one when we understand that we are miles and miles far away from the level of preparation needed, that we catch the difference between:
- What we think to know / control and what really we know / control
- What is really effective and what absolutely not (read How to know if a combat technique works or not)
- What we are truly able to perform and what not (especially under stress)
- What we should have focused our preparation on and what we did instead
- How we were trained and how we would have to train (read Is your instructor harming your martial growth?)
- Physical training and mental preparation (to the stress level of real scenarios, read )
- The limited human reflexes and the effectiveness of constant attention (read Constant attention: what is and how it works)
- …
What does the ineffectiveness of a martial preparation depend on?
The limit lies in us.
In front of the failure, the illusion fades immediately and instead of blaming ourselves for our superficiality (lack of reasoning in choosing our self-defense path, concentration on training quality, etc.), we unload the responsibility for our errors on the martial art, which,Ā in a lot of cases (directly or indirectly):
- Has been adopted in life vs death battlefields for thousands of years (eg. traditional styles)
- Is employed by special military forces of half of the world (eg. modern warfare fighting systems)
- Is used at the highest levels of athletic competitionĀ (eg. UFC)
The fact is that in 75-80% of cases, the guilt is ours and the most common reasons are:
- Too high expectations and too low preparationĀ – Through movies, poor “instructors” (read Recognize a good / bad master: 5 characteristics), too high reference points (etc.), we have been introduced to an all-exasperated and imaginative view of martial arts (“magic” shots that annihilate anyone, effortless victories, one-week secret technique’s learning, hundreds of simultaneous opponents, etc., read also Martial arts: movies VS reality, 7 differences and Forget everything you know about multiple opponents fighting)
- We do not focus on learning the right things (in the right way)Ā – We spend more time dreaming of being good rather than training, chasing titles rather than real abilities (read All the skills of 6 Dragons Kung Fu), calling ourselves experts rather than searching / correcting our defects, criticizing the others rather than facing them in not-cooperative sparring sets (read The meaning of sparring fighting in martial arts), focusing on physical violence instead of learning to use the mind to prevent / manage critical issues (read ), etc.
If we seek effectiveness, in terms of self-defense, there are no shortcuts
It is foolish to wait to jeopardize our safety (or that of those around us) to open our eyes and draw a furrow between:
- Reality and fantasy
- Serious training and waste of time
- The instructors that increase our capabilities and those that limit it
- The teachings that endanger our lives and those that could save them
- …
Real self-defense preparation requires dedication, sacrifice, focus and this is not for everyone.
Anyone who thinks to be smarter than others aiming at shortcuts, effortless tricks (etc.), soon or later will find himself / herself having to deal with the tough reality:
- People become good at what they do most – For example, an exquisite pastry chef is likely to be, at least, a discreet cook but it is equally unlikely that he could compete with an expert who has devoted his / her whole life to cooking fish; the same reasoning applies to martial arts, if we have spent our lives doing sublime acrobatics (or cool moves), how can we hope to resist to those who (for the same amount of time) have done nothing but fighting (even at a rough level)?
- The only working techniques and tactics are the ones we have completely masteredĀ – While, on the one hand, it is true that a good knowledge of combat technique gives us a remarkable advantage over an inexperienced opponent, it is equally true that an average knowledge puts us below his / her level (read A scheme to quickly learn any kind of technique); everything that does not comes simple and spontaneous as walking should never be used in real combat (read How to learn faster)
- Forms, sequences, drills, techniques and fighting sets are useless without sparring and conditioning – While, on one hand, it is true that forms (eg. from Karate or Kung Fu) help us to train precision, balance, trajectories (etc.) is just as true that they do not give us any rudiment for a real clash (read Are Karate’s Kata, Kung Fu’s form (etc.) useless?); the struggle is something live, unpredictable and always different; forms have not been studied for this, they were born as a method of transmission (without conditioning and sparring they are useless, read )
- Even if our body is athletically prepared, we are only at 50% of the work – If our mind is weak we will probably fail; prevention, negotiation, planning, stress management (etc.) are fundamental abilities that no one who is seriously interested in self-defense can ignore; if we think that things like muscles and aggressivity can solve any kind of situation we are simply foolish
- …
Self-defense: have a wide range of possibilities
To gain good results, we must carry out all that is fundamental to our goal (not necessarily linked only to the struggle):
- Ability to manage our emotions (read for example How to use emotions in workout and combat)
- Planning attitude to prevent problems (read
- Daily physical training (read How to start practicing 6DKF and )
- Regularly do sparring sessions (read How to do sparring)
- Perform not collaborative and / or improvised simulations (read How to simulate realistic self-defense scenarios)
- …
Let’s be clear, no one can excel in everything (mental aspects, strength, etc.) but we must, at the same time:
- Privilege what we are good at
- Improve what we are lacking
On the street, it’s only by maintaining a broad vision that we can get (at least) a possibility to prevail: this way we can always count on a small advantage (eg. good use of legs, advanced flexibility, deception capability, speed of execution, etc.) in front of eventual opponents with overwhelming skills.
A note by master Kongling – Even for the combat techniques, we always need to have more than one choice available: let’s beware of those who offer us a single possibility of liberation, attack, defense, counterattack (etc.). We are all different from each other, as are our adversaries, weapons, environments of struggle, present mental dispositions (etc.); all this causes an entropy that is completely unpredictable and impossible to solve with (ridiculous) generic answers.
In-depth articles
- Martial art and self-defense: what are the differences? – The discriminant between safety and martial study
- 6DKF: what does it teach?Ā – The sources and the focus of 6 Dragons Kung Fu’s system
Questions
Reply in the comments and share your experience:
- Have you ever faced a fighter stronger than you?
Author: Master Kongling
Founder of 6 Dragons Kung Fu.How to master 6 Dragons Kung Fu?
Are you searching for:
- Daily training exercises?
- Synthetic theory and concepts?
- A step by step path from white to black belt?
- A path (clear, consequential and gradual) designed to build real martial skills?
- A direct contact with Master Kongling?
Go to our Patreon page and choose a training plan: starting from the Practitioner level, you will gain access to all this and much more.
Inside each Premium Lesson, you will receive the same teaching (practices, tips, concepts, small secrets and corrections) reserved to the live students of Master Kongling.
Important - Once a certain number of registrations are reached, no other participants can be accepted. For more information write to: [email protected].
YanLei
December 19, 2017 @ 1:58 am
Do you mean training is the most important part of martial arts learning?
Master Kongling
December 19, 2017 @ 10:18 am
Yes, if you follow that kind of 1-hour-course per week and you never do sparring, never train specific abilities, you can be in a slightly better psychophysical condition but you are very far from being able to prevail in a real fight.
To be able to play tennis you have to play not only study the theory, to play football, it’s the same, to play golf it’s the same, to cook you need to cook… why for martial arts should be different?